Comments

• SpideyCU Member

  August 20

  @Treisk said:

  This can be best described very simply --
  - All melee units now have heavy armor. They also deal full damage to all units.
  - Most ranged units deal Projectile damage, which deals full damage to ranged units but reduced damage to heavy units.
  - Finally, some units have Piercing damage, which does full damage to heavy units.

  But what does Piercing do to ranged units? Half?

  If it does full, then it's the same as melee units but with range?
• Foamborn Member

  August 20

  Vespid Carrier

  Health: 135 ⇒ 250
  Movement speed: 3.9 ⇒ 4.1

  

  Also what is unit-walking?
• Millea Member

  August 21

  @Foamborn

  Unit walking means that they can walk through other units now.
• wondible Member

  August 21

  Click anywhere to exit still seems to be click the bottom to exit.

  Maybe I just need to master multiple groups, but I often have issues with order of battle. Especially in the early game, I want the hero tanking for more fragile units, and this takes some shuffling. Healers also like to rush to the front, or even go hug the enemy.
• Deaucalion Member

  August 21

  Progression: I and a few other people noticed that some matches were not rewarding currency.

  As discussed during the playtest, Frostfall is wrecking the more fragile T1 units. Treisk mentioned that the plan was to halve the damage done to these units by switching the ability's damage type to Piercing. That sounds like a good change, though I think the damage could be even a little lower (~40%). It also might be worth looking at the damage available from the ugrade.

  Besides that the game feels pretty good right now. Switching to a binary Normal/Heavy scheme preserves the intent of the system while making it a lot easier to grok (still needs a name update to Light/Heavy or Unarmored/Armored).

  I've always thought that the physical/magical damage system was a bit of an uncomfortable fit for the game. My impression (which may be incorrect) is that even a "caster squad" like Vex does the greater percentage of its damage through physical auto-attack damage. Some of the high-damage abilities that are technically most affected by percentage adjustments do so much damage that magical damage and magical resist upgrades don't significantly change the functional impact of the ability. These are the natural niches for auto-attacks and abilities in an RTS, but because of this I don't think they lend themselves to the same kind of upgrade system.

  I also used to get confused about whether some abilities did physical or magical damage. The documentation has gotten a lot better, and this isn't as much of an issue now. Still, it could be helpful to tie damage bonuses and resistance to more tangible qualities, like splash damage or damage over time. Perhaps different factions could have different upgrades; for example blue gets splash damage buffs while red gets increased/extended burn damage.
• CohLysion Member

  August 21

  General Comments

  Titans
  (1.1) - Didn't get to play too many games tonight, but the fights in the center are still feeling pretty good. I love the new FX, particularly the cone slam and the roar. Artura or what ever the planet is called is a more mysterious place, now with vindictive dimensional portals.

  Replays
  (2.1) - This was the first time in a while that I'd looked at a replay, so I'm not sure how much just went in. Overall, I like the feel of it, though the interface takes up a bit more space than I expected. Overall, feel of working with it was smooth.

  Damage and Armor Types
  (3.1) - Early on, damage systems changed a fair amount, such that I didn't really learn to pay too much attention to them (would just bookmark it to come back to later). If you guys wanted to make the system more explicit, maybe could reflect the damage reduction in the floating numbers. That would maybe be easier than post-processing damage done, but would still help illustrate what is mitigating your damage. Who knows, maybe change the color of the text based on if it is damage type or target upgrades that are reducing damage? While at it, could also change color based on magic or physical damage.
• tedster Member

  August 22 edited August 22

  I'll be having nightmares about Frostcallers for years (otherwise I really really like this patch)
• Deaucalion Member

  August 22

  Wait... AlphaGo knows how to play Atlas?! The AI is taking over!
• TokOwa Member

  August 23 edited August 23

  Hey, I would like to give some thoughts and feelings on two of the T1.5 units.

  Aquanauts

  These seem way too squishy for being a 'sturdy, well-rounded' unit. They have good dps, but doesn't seem to have the sturdiness to actually get into situations and deal it out properly, Compared to the powerlevel of Howling Commando's, whom many agree are in a good spot. Suggestions include various means of making them 'sturdier'. The biggest issue is that their 'identifying' ability happens way too infrequently to actually feel like a significant part of their kit. Increasing the uptime and spammability of the ability would make their 'identity' more noticeable.

  Suggested Changes:
  Armor Type: Normal => Heavy
  OR
  Health Points: 140 => 220
  Cooldown on Ice Shield: 12 sec => 8 sec
  OR
  Health Points 140 => 180
  Cooldown on Ice Shield: 12 sec => 6 sec

  Note: I also contemplated whether Unit Cap: 8 => 6 would be necessary with these kinds of changes, but I generally wanted to avoid that. I don't think it is necessary.

  Cinder Beetles

  These units have the identity of strong melee units with a 'positional element' in that when they spawn the Cinderlings, they gain a temporary advantage. It is very similar to Seedbots' saplings, but have a slight different form. This is an interesting unit, and is very cool. One big issue is with controlling the ability. It would be better to be able to click a certain area where the Cinderlings are getting sent at. We've discussed this already and I'm only including for completeness.

  The other issue that I personally have with their ability is the upgrade. The upgrade allows the Cinder Beetle to cast their baby beetles a last time when they die. I think the suicidal nature of the unit post-upgrade makes it very off-putting. While I agree that sometimes the spawned Cinderlings can assist in an even fight, however, most of the time, losing your Cinder Beetles will happen in situations where the Cinderlings will have almost no impact, like in a stupid mistake or poke wars where there is no intention of actually engaging and closing the gap with the enemy. So my suggested change aims at giving the Cinder Beetle's ability more Oomph. I think it is in line with Red's explosive nature, and will amplify the Cinderbeetle's positional power as the game goes on.

  Suggested Change:
  Ability Name: Vengeful Progenies => Advanced Cinderfacturing
  Ability: Spawn Cinderlings now spawns 3 additional Cinderlings.

  Unrelated Change Suggestion:
  Energy Cost: 7 => 6
  Damage: 21 => 19

  Note: For the unrelated change suggestion, I just felt that the 7 energy cost was out of place, especially compared to other T1.5's. If there is any specific reason for the 7 energy cost, I would be curious to know.
• tedster Member

  August 23 edited August 23

  I agree with Tokowa's observations to a large degree, especially on the suicidal nature of the Cinder Beetle upgrade. An upgrade designed to trigger only when you are "losing" is going to feel bad the majority of the time, even if it's good, which i don't think it is.

  I do, however, think Aquanauts could use a damage buff to help differentiate them from other units and give blue some powerful sustained DPS at tier 1.5. It's possible that a buff to survivability might help enough already, but I would expect them to still feel relatively low-impact even if they were a bit harder to pick off.
• TokOwa Member

  August 23 edited August 23

  While I do agree that your change (increased DPS) would make the unit better and more useful, the goal of my suggestion was more to push the unit towards its identity, which is more like an 'immortal-esque' unit. I think keeping the thematic uniqueness of the factions is a good thing, and a high-impact ranged dps doesn't really fit into the high-utility\high defensiveness theme of blue.

  To clarify, I'm not saying that high-dps doesn't belong in blue, but in the current form it kinda comes in at a later stage in more situational ways, which is good, as it provides this kind of ramping feel. I just don't think a high-dps option fits thematically as a T1.5 from the get-go.
• TokOwa Member

  August 23

  Feeling particularly inspired today, so I'm going to give my comments on the Nautilusks as well.

  Nautilusks

  These guys. The frontline and pride of the Empire of Ometa. They are equipped with the latest protective technology and sent to fight the most menacing and largest beasts of the ocean realms (whom are thought to be the largest beasts in the world). With their bare hands. This makes no sense at all. Give the guys a spear. Or a trident.

  The Nautilusks are very tanky. But they often do not pose any threat or have any clear role within the Blue Army. People will just kite, and if they don't kite, as in the case of many melee unit, Nautilusks don't deal enough dmg to pose a great threat. They deserve a trident.

  Suggested Changes:
  Damage: 22 => 40
  Damage Type: Normal => Piercing
  Attack Range: Melee => 2
  Movement Speed: 4.7 => 4.3

  Changes aims at making them a soft-counter to heavy armored melee units, while giving them a slight nerf to Normal armored units. Attack range gives them 'First strike' against many melee units, but the lowered movement speed makes it hard to do any kiting shenanigans. Some people might think that the movement speed debuff is too harsh, but I think it is necessarily to keep them at a 15/20 shard level rather than at 30 shards. It doesn't undermine their identity, which another nerf might do. Unit Cap could possibly go from 6 back to 8.
• tedster Member

  August 23

  I would agree that right now Nautilusks feel a bit too easy to kite without having clear roles, especially due to the released reliance of Blue on Quadrapi. On the other hand, I feel like Slugs should be the counterpick to heavy tanks rather than putting that on the all-purpose tanky T1.5, so I'm not sure these would be the changes I'd personally make. Further nerfing the movespeed on Nautilusks also seems tough.
• excal Member, Administrator

  August 24

  Definitely agreed that the Nautilusk and Aquanaut are not in a healthy place right now. And TokOwa, that's a super interesting direction to take the Nautilusk - definitely not an approach we'd considered. I'm interested in re-shaping its identity a bit, but we might just go with a simple buff for now.